01 · The short version
A very small improvement covers the cost
HD Supply’s digital business is large enough that the annual Customer Journey Analytics (CJA) investment is covered by about $1 of extra revenue for every $7,800 of existing digital revenue. Everything that follows shows how we got there, and what still needs your validation.
What the model assumes
A 0.05% measurable improvement on a provisional $3.8 billion digital revenue baseline, a 20% contribution rate, and benefit that ramps 50% / 80% / 100% over three years. These are deliberately conservative planning assumptions, not predictions about HD Supply’s performance.
What is checked and what is not
The arithmetic has been validated. The business inputs have not yet been approved by HD Supply Finance: the revenue baseline, contribution rate, improvement assumption, ramp, and the way incremental value will be measured. The right conclusion is that the economics justify moving to validation, not that the outcome is guaranteed.
02 · Why this matters to HD Supply
The buying journey doesn’t stay in one system
A buyer may respond to marketing, research products on the website, sign in to a business account, move into a PunchOut or e-procurement platform, and finish the order in a separate transaction system. Web analytics sees the first part. The transaction system sees the last part. Today, those are not always analyzed as one journey.
- MarketingCampaigns and media
- Digital researchWebsite and product browsing
- Authenticated buyerBusiness account sign-in
- Procurement / PunchOutWhere visibility is often lost
- TransactionOrder completed in a separate system
Connect outcomes
Link web activity to procurement and transaction outcomes.
Analyze at scale
Look at journeys for the individual buyer and for the whole business account.
Find opportunity
Identify friction, commercial influence, growth signals, and risk.
CJA does not connect everything automatically. It needs reliable person, account, procurement, and transaction identifiers across environments, with governed data definitions and validation. Confirming those is part of the next steps. The value is not simply having more data in one place; it comes from making a better decision, acting on it, and measuring the result.
Five places connected insight can create value
Digital commerce
Find friction and opportunity across a large existing digital business. Because the revenue base is significant, even a small measurable improvement can be meaningful economic value.
- Which digital experiences contribute to downstream orders?
- Where do customers hit friction between research and purchase?
E-procurement
Connect digital research and engagement with orders that are completed in a separate purchasing environment. It is the clearest example of the connected-journey problem.
- Which product-research behaviors precede procurement orders?
- Which products get lots of research but little procurement activity?
Account growth
Several buyers often interact with the same business account. A single-buyer view can miss the buying group. An account view helps surface expansion signals (rising research without matching revenue) and risk signals (declining frequency or reorders).
Repeat purchasing
Follow the path from first order to replenishment to the next order, and identify the experiences and behaviors associated with retention.
Marketing effectiveness
Connect media activity to downstream commercial outcomes so allocation decisions can be judged against return on ad spend (ROAS), HD Supply’s primary efficiency KPI.
Scale comparison only: the $97,560 annual investment is about 1% of annual media spend. Moving budget is not itself a benefit; value counts only when the better allocation produces a measurable result.
Account growth, repeat purchasing, marketing influence, and e-procurement may all show up in the same digital revenue. The primary financial case therefore uses one consolidated digital-commerce improvement so no value is counted twice.
03 · The financial case
From a $3.8 billion base to $380,000 a year
The conservative case is the primary decision scenario. Each step is one multiplication, so every number can be checked and replaced with HD Supply’s own.
Why not use the $1.9M?
Incremental revenue is revenue above what HD Supply would otherwise have produced. Generating, serving, and fulfilling it costs money, so counting all $1.9M would overstate the value. The $380,000 is the figure used in the ROI.
Both assumptions are placeholders for your numbers
The 0.05% and 20% are illustrative, not claims about HD Supply’s performance or profitability. HD Supply Finance should confirm the baseline and replace the 20% with the contribution rate, gross margin, or other measure you use for incremental revenue.
Value builds over time
Connecting data, building capability, driving adoption, changing decisions, and measuring results all take time, so $380K is not multiplied by three. The model realizes 50% of it in Year 1, 80% in Year 2, and 100% in Year 3.
Year 1
50% realization$380K × 50% = $190K
Through Year 2
80% realization$380K × 80% = $304K
Through Year 3
100% realization$380K × 100% = $380K
Bars show cumulative figures. ROI = cumulative net benefit ÷ cumulative investment. For example, $581,320 ÷ $292,680 ≈ 199%. These are modeled projections, not guaranteed outcomes; actual value depends on implementation, data readiness, adoption, business actions, and measured incremental improvement.
Show the full year-by-year table
| Period | Benefit that year | Cumulative benefit | Cumulative investment | Cumulative net benefit | Cumulative ROI |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $190K | $190K | $97,560 | $92,440 | 95% |
| Through Year 2 | $304K | $494K | $195,120 | $298,880 | 153% |
| Through Year 3 | $380K | $874K | $292,680 | $581,320 | 199% |
04 · Investment and Adobe’s contribution
Recurring cost and one-time support, kept separate
The recurring investment is judged against the recurring benefit. Adobe’s implementation support lowers the cost and risk of getting started, but it is never counted as ongoing business benefit.
Incremental annual CJA investment
The recurring cost evaluated against the recurring benefit.
Three-year investment in the model
Three full annual periods ($97,560 × 3). No ROI credit is taken for the 90-day billing transition, which keeps the cost treatment conservative.
Adobe implementation support at no additional charge
One-time transition support. It reduces upfront cost and risk, and is not counted in ROI.
How Adobe lowers the cost and risk of the transition
- A 90-day transition period before CJA billing begins
- Adobe Analytics stays available throughout the transition
- Increased Analytics transition capacity and a waiver of pending overages
- Parallel validation before migration, so numbers can be compared side by side
The ROI case is designed to stand on the recurring economics alone. The $220K of support is upside to the risk profile, not a number in the return.
05 · The break-even hurdle
Work backward from the cost
The 199% ROI shows what the conservative assumptions produce. The more decision-useful question is the reverse: how much improvement is needed just to cover the annual cost? This does not say CJA automatically creates that improvement. It says how high the bar is.
Digital commerce
Against the $3.8B baseline
$97,560 ÷ 20% = $487,800 of incremental revenue needed.
$487,800 ÷ $3.8B ≈
0.013%
Compare with the 0.05% used in the conservative case.
E-procurement, as a stand-alone test
Against the $764M baseline
The same $487,800 of incremental revenue needed.
$487,800 ÷ $764M ≈
0.064%
Not a forecast. A way to see the hurdle inside one specific, relevant part of the business.
Why e-procurement is the natural place to prove it
It is a commercially important journey that spans several environments: the digital experience holds the signals of intent, interest, and friction, and the procurement system holds the final order. When they cannot be analyzed together, it is hard to see how the whole journey influenced the outcome.
Questions a connected view can answer
- Which digital experiences precede procurement orders?
- Where do buyers hit friction between the digital and procurement environments?
- How does marketing engagement contribute to e-procurement revenue?
- Which journey improvements lead to measurable procurement results?
E-procurement is already part of the $3.8 billion digital base, so it is used here to illustrate where improvement could be found and measured. It is not added on top of the three-year ROI.
06 · Test the assumptions
Change the inputs and watch the result move
Use the sliders to try HD Supply’s own baseline, improvement, and contribution rate. The 50% / 80% / 100% ramp and the $97,560 annual investment stay fixed. Nothing you enter leaves this page.
Three reference scenarios: sensitivities, not forecasts
The scenarios are mutually exclusive views of the same digital-commerce lever. They should not be added together or presented as predictions.
| Scenario | Core assumption | Annual contribution | 3-yr net benefit | 3-yr ROI |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conservative (primary) | 0.05% revenue; 20% contribution | $380K | $581K | ~199% |
| Base sensitivity | 0.10% revenue; 30% contribution | $1.14M | $2.33M | ~796% |
| Upside sensitivity | 0.25% revenue; 30% contribution | $2.85M | $6.26M | ~2,140% |
The larger outputs show how much the result depends on the assumptions. They are not expected outcomes.
07 · From modeled value to measured value
How we will know the value is real
CJA supplies the analysis and measurement foundation. Economic value is created only when a connected insight leads to a better decision and that decision produces a measurable outcome.
Identify the opportunity
Use connected journey analysis to find friction, commercial influence, growth or risk signals.
Take a business action
Change an experience, audience, marketing decision, procurement journey, or account strategy.
Measure the outcome
Track KPIs such as conversion, incremental revenue, contribution, procurement activity, repeat purchase, account growth, and ROAS.
Validate incremental value
Observed improvement is not proof of cause. Use a credible comparison: a controlled experiment, holdout, matched group, geographic test, or another method Finance approves.
Guardrails that keep the case credible
- Revenue is not treated as profit. A Finance-approved contribution measure is applied.
- One-time support and recurring benefit stay separate.
- Overlapping outcomes are not counted twice.
- Reallocating media spend is not automatically counted as savings.
- The model is recalculated whenever an input changes.
Inputs HD Supply Finance should confirm
| $3.8B digital revenue baseline |
| $764M e-procurement revenue baseline |
| Contribution rate on incremental revenue |
| 0.05% improvement assumption |
| 50% / 80% / 100% realization ramp |
| Recurring CJA investment |
| Method for validating incremental value |
For each: business definition, system of record, included population and channels, reporting period, owner, and approved value.
Why some operating numbers don’t reconcile, and how we handle it
The operating metrics came from different source systems, populations, channels, or periods. For example, 7.06M digital orders × a $485 average order value is about $3.42B, not $3.8B, and 2.80M e-procurement orders × $485 is about $1.36B, versus a reported $764M.
Rather than force the numbers to agree, we keep them as separate planning inputs. The formulas are valid on the stated inputs, but the $3.8B baseline should be confirmed independently with Finance, and the ROI recalculated if it changes.
08 · Q&A